Lump Sum Payment or Structured Settlement? ($1000 Giveaway!)

Getting a Good Car Insurance Settlement

The result of my car accident.

In July 2011, I totalled my fiance’s car. We were driving back to the city from our rural hometown, and the traffic was bad on the highway. I was in the driver’s seat of the trusty old red neon, and my fiance (then boyfriend) was trying to snooze a bit on this three hour drive.

I was passing a white van when it began to veer into my lane. I couldn’t slow down because of the traffic behind me, so I laid on the horn and got as far over onto the shoulder as I could. The driver of the white van hadn’t checked her blind spot, and she kept coming. Once the two vehicles collided, I remember very little, but somehow the car (after spinning) ended up facing the right way on the opposite shoulder of the highway.

I ended up with a broken wrist from that experience, and more than a healthy fear of driving in traffic. For these things I was entitled a settlement, but it would be over a year before I saw one. Finally, after much persistence on my part, and much evasion on the insurance company’s part, I got a $2,000 lump sum payment.

I’m really happy to have gotten a lump sum payment instead of a structured settlement, which would have spread out the amount over several payments. A lump sum payment allowed me to pay off a good chunk of my student debt, which has significantly helped me maintain my enthusiasm for debt repayment in general. It doesn’t change the fact that my wrist will forever be weak, or that my heart races when I’m surrounded by traffic, but it helps.

Lump sum payments are better for many reasons. It doesn’t allow inflation to eat away at the value of the money, it allows you to take immediate advantage of a large sum of money (either to invest for a return or to pay off debt for a return.) Finally, you never know what life is going to throw at you, and taking the cash right away to either save, invest, or pay off debt will immediately improve your situation.

$1,000 Give Away

Sometimes bad stuff happens, but sometimes awesome stuff happens too, and today, I’m hoping to make some awesome stuff happen for one of you readers. I’m participating in a $1,000 giveaway in collaboration with several other bloggers, and I sincerely hope that the prize goes to one of you! Maybe you can use it to pay down some debt, invest, or put into savings. I know that for many people (including myself), $1,000 could make a huge difference in your financial situation.

To enter, simply fill out the requirements in the Rafflecopter widget below. This giveaway was brought to you by StructuredSettlement-Quotes.com, America’s #1 structured settlement and annuity marketplace.

a Rafflecopter giveaway

If you won $1,000, what would you spend it on?

  • http://www.monsterpiggybank.com/ Glen @ Monster Piggy Bank

    That is a crazy scary story. I’m so glad you are OK now.

    • http://my-alternate-life.com/ Jordann

      Thanks! It was scary, but I’ve put it behind me.

  • http://twitter.com/RFIndependence Pauline

    I would take the lump sum and move on with my life! Being tied to a company that did you wrong has to be an emotional drain somehow.

    • http://my-alternate-life.com/ Jordann

      It certainly was an emotional drain when I was trying to get the money out of them! I was definitely ready to be done with the whole ordeal by the time I finally received my payment.

  • John S @ Frugal Rules

    Wow, glad you’re ok and that it wasn’t a worse accident. I would take the lump sum as well. If I got $1000 cash right now I’d put it towards a vacation…practical I know. :)

    • http://my-alternate-life.com/ Jordann

      Hey, don’t knock vacations, they’re important!

  • Jason @ WorkSaveLive

    Wow, what a terrifying experience. Fortunately I’ve never had anything like that happen. At least you got compensated…how ridiculous is it that the insurance company tried to get out of paying you? Grrr.

    • http://my-alternate-life.com/ Jordann

      Oh man it was awful how many times I had to follow up with them, how many times they lost my info, they were counting on me to give up.

  • http://twitter.com/PlungedinDebt Plunged in Debt

    I’ve been on a few car accidents, no matter how big or small they are terrifying. So glad you’re ok and got the settlement that was entitled to you!

    • http://my-alternate-life.com/ Jordann

      This one was only my second one, and I hope it’s my last!

  • http://budgetandthebeach.com/ Budget & the Beach

    Glad that accident wasn’t worse! But still, they are freaky. I’ve been in a couple myself.

    • http://my-alternate-life.com/ Jordann

      They suck, no doubt about it.

  • http://twitter.com/FreeAgentRogers Rod J. Rogers

    An extra $1,000.00? I THINK I’d give it to my favorite charity. But I think I’d better take my wife out to a really fine restaurant first, and give the rest to charity.

    • http://my-alternate-life.com/ Jordann

      That’s a great way to spend it! I’m not at virtuous as you, I’d probably put it towards my debt, or my wedding.

  • holly

    Thanks for co-hosting! If I won $1,000, I would probably save it towards a vacation or throw it towards my mortgage.

    • http://my-alternate-life.com/ Jordann

      Those are both great places to put an extra $1k!

  • Goldeneer

    I wonder what interest they pay for a structured settlement. That is a scary accident to be involved in and its too bad that you had additional stress from having to deal with the uncooperative insurance company.

    • http://my-alternate-life.com/ Jordann

      I’m not sure about interest, I’ve never done a structured payment. Yes, dealing with the insurance company was annoying, I’m glad that’s over with!

  • http://dropthatdebt.wordpress.com/ Drop that Debt

    Umm whoa!! This is awesome Jordann. Great stuff :) Sorry to hear about the accident but glad it helped with some loans at least.

    • http://my-alternate-life.com/ Jordann

      Yup, it sucked but it had that little extra benefit. Although, if I hadn’t totalled the car, I wouldn’t be paying $200 a month for a new to me one right now, which would’ve helped way more!

  • http://www.outliermodel.com/ OutlierModel

    Thanks for co-hosting! I think right now, if I won $1000, it’d go into our vacation money for this year. :)