Discerning Wants Vs. Needs

A great way to start saving money is learning to decipher what you need in life, versus what you want in life. When I first started getting out of debt, and reducing my spending, I had a lot of “needs”. I needed to get my hair done every six weeks. I needed to go to yoga once a week. I needed to spend money on my wardrobe. I needed to buy as much of my food as possible from the local farmer’s market. With all of these needs, I was finding it really hard to find enough money in my budget to pay my upcoming student loan payments.

Eventually, just to get the numbers to balance, I had to resign myself to the fact that I was going to have to say goodbye to a lot of these needs. Once I’d stopped going to yoga, and stopped getting my hair cut so frequently, I realized that these things weren’t in fact needs at all. I wasn’t indulging in them anymore, but I was fine. Nope, those things were wants, masquerading as needs.

Beware the Want in Need’s Clothing

This happens a lot, people have needs, that aren’t in fact needs at all. This is what needs are: Food, shelter, heat, transportation, and enough clothing and personal care to keep you from losing your job. That’s pretty much it! Everything else is a want.

There’s nothing wrong with wants. Wanting things, and indulging in things that aren’t a necessity are what makes life worth living. Let’s just call a spade a spade here. The worst want, is the want that is pretending to be a need. I came up against this issue recently.

I take my coffee to work with me every day. I take it with me in a reusable coffee mug that my fiance got me for my birthday last year. When he first got it for me, it was absolutely perfect. It kept my coffee hot for hours and was completely leak proof, allowing me to throw it into my bag along with my electronics without having to worry about ruining anything.

Over time though, the mug has become … well used. Honestly, it’s starting to make my coffee taste gross. I blame the construction. There’s plastic on the inside of the container, instead of stainless steal. I can’t complain, the thing was made to hold tea, not it’s much more potent cousin. I’ve been considering kinda replacing it, but not really.

Until this week. This week it’s really gotten into my head that I need a new coffee mug. So much so that I even started browsing online for one (!). I found a suitable replacement for around $20. Before I hit “add to cart”, I paused for a moment.

Why was I suddenly interested in getting a new coffee mug?
My mug had been tasting gross for awhile, why the sudden uptick in interest?

knowing the difference between wants and needsThen I realized why. This Saturday, I’d been in Starbucks. I’d seen this pretty lady on the right, and that had gotten me thinking about getting a new mug.

It wasn’t because I needed one.
It wasn’t because it was time to replace my old mug.

It was because I’d been in a store, seen something I’d liked, and that image had swum around in the depths of my consciousness and emerged as the idea that I needed to replace my current coffee mug.

So I didn’t.

I closed the browser, and decided to go through another month or two of slightly stale tasting coffee before replacing my mug.

I didn’t need that new, tall, shiny, mug, I wanted it. I’d almost successfully fooled myself into thinking I needed it, but I caught myself just in time.

A lot of your are probably thinking “what’s the big deal? Just buy the damn mug!”. Well yes, that would make sense if I had plenty of cash to pay for it. The truth is though, I have better things to do with my money, like building up my chequing account buffer, and paying off a pesky bit of credit card debt that has somehow jumped onto my back. Until those things are taken care of, I’ll deal with my stale tasting coffee mug.

Once I’ve accomplished those few things on my check list, I’ll indulge my want, guilt free. I’ll do that because while little sacrifices like this can make the difference between getting out of debt and staying on the credit treadmill forever, it’s also little indulgences like a new coffee mug that can be the difference between sticking to the plan and total frugality induced insanity.

What “wants” do you have that are probably really “needs”? Don’t feel guilty about them, indulging in wants is what makes life interesting!

  • http://twitter.com/RFIndependence Pauline

    I kind of need a computer and an internet connection since I do everything online but didn’t need it so bad 10 years ago. Wants and need evolve..

    • http://my-alternate-life.com/ Jordann

      Wants and needs definitely evolve! 10 years ago, I would’ve considered cable a need. Now, I haven’t had cable in five years and I don’t miss it.

  • FrugalPortland

    now it’s time to pitch coffee mug companies and do a giveaway…

    • http://my-alternate-life.com/ Jordann

      My thoughts exactly! Know of any local/handmade/socially responsible retailers who might be interested?

      • FrugalPortland

        maybe Kleen Kanteen?

        • http://my-alternate-life.com/ Jordann

          Oo good idea, I’ve loved their products for years.

  • http://twitter.com/NewlywedsBudget Newlyweds ona Budget

    honey, give me your address and I’ll send you a mug! haha, They sell high end coffee mugs at places like HomeGoods, for like $7 (I would never spend $20 on a coffee mug!). so seriously, $7 is not going to kill you from paying off your debt or saving money : ) there are not a lot of things in life we need to survive, but it’s the wants that make it worth the ride : )

    • http://my-alternate-life.com/ Jordann

      I hate how everything is more expensive in Canada! I agree, if I really want a new coffee mug, I’ll buy one, but I think I can wait a few more months. :)

      • Soverypoor

        I agree with Newlyweds. There is a fine line between being smart with your money and depriving yourself.

        I had a recent conversation with my financial advisor and he mentioned that he thinks we (myself and boyfriend) won’t spend money on ourselves because we show tenancies to save a lot or put it all against our student loans.

        Sometimes, you just have to get something that gives you please, like a travel mug. So I think… buy it! Before you end up ‘binge shopping’.

        • http://my-alternate-life.com/ Jordann

          Thanks for your opinion! I’ll definitely buy it before I binge shop. I’ve gone down that road before.

  • Country Girl

    I always struggle with wants vs needs. This week my want/need struggle has been with furniture. I would love a new couch, but I certainly don’t need it. My old green couch holds my ass just fine. It doesn’t help though knowing the January is the best time to buy clearance furniture :P

    • http://my-alternate-life.com/ Jordann

      I hear ya on that one. I want a new couch so bad. Mine is too small for two people to spread out on comfortably.

  • http://budgetandthebeach.com/ Budget & the Beach

    I hate when coffee mugs start making your coffee taste like shit. grrr. But I would imagine there are much cheaper ones out there! Mine is probably a hair cut. I have shortish hair, so if I don’t get it cut every 8 weeks (and that’s pushing it for me) I start to hate the way I look. My hair looks limp and stringy. So I admit it’s more of a want than a need. No one is holding a gun to my stringy-haired head. :)

    • http://my-alternate-life.com/ Jordann

      Hair cuts were a tough one for me too, now I wear my hair long, so it doesn’t need to be cut as often.

  • Mo cdnbudgetbinder

    I don’t really struggle much with wants and needs as we are so focused on saving and investing. We do need a computer but are just holding back until this one dies I think although on the odd occasion we have been tempted to just run out and buy one. It’s all a strength and understanding about where you want to go and how fast you are willing to work on it to get there. Great post.

    • http://my-alternate-life.com/ Jordann

      Exactly! Everything is a trade off. Buying something now means delaying future goals. Sometimes that’s worth it, other times it’s not.

  • AvgJoeMoney

    Awesome! I fight this battle daily. Why am I buying this? Is it because I really need new flip flops? My current flip flops are just fine if I hold the little center thingy that’s broken down with my big toe….

    Even if I DO need it I play games to see how long I can hold on. I have a broken garage door that clearly needs attention. I really don’t want to deal with the service call or the cost right now. Let’s see if I can go without the garage for a month or two….. At some point it becomes an energy drainer and needs to be replaced…just not today.

    • http://my-alternate-life.com/ Jordann

      Exactly! If something needs to be replaced but isn’t bugging you just yet, then it’s not quite time yet. Once it becomes a hassle or a frustration, then it’s time.

  • John S @ Frugal Rules

    Good post Jordann! I think we all fight this battle daily, I mean we’re human after all. It can be very easy to rationalize a want into a need if we allow ourselves to. You have to find a balance, because otherwise life is just too boring.

    • http://my-alternate-life.com/ Jordann

      Couldn’t agree more!

  • http://www.uniquegifter.com/ Anne @ Unique Gifter

    Nice identification! My current struggle is wanting a new laptop because mine is now functioning as a desktop. Do I need it? Heck no! Do I really want it? Yes. Will waiting six months result in me having one that lasts six months longer, with six month newer specs? Yes. Now – if only I could bring in $800 from the internet to justify it to myself, HA!

    • http://my-alternate-life.com/ Jordann

      Ugh, my lap top is not doing too hot lately either. It’s battery life has been severely reduced, rendering it mostly a desktop. A new one just isn’t in the cards right now though, so I guess it’ll have to do for awhile longer!

  • http://www.vanessasmoney.com/ Vanessa

    I’m a coffee nut so I would have gotten the new mug right away (especially if it leaks!). Everyone has their priorities right? ;)

    • http://my-alternate-life.com/ Jordann

      Yup! Everyone’s are different.

  • Pingback: Link Love/Week in Review 1/17/13 | Budget and the Beach

  • Pingback: Link Love, Vol. 2 | Break the Sky

  • http://twitter.com/prairieecothrif Miss T

    Way to go with the willpower. Delayed gratification will make that first cup in the new mug taste even better. Good for you for recognizing this difficult distinction.

    • http://my-alternate-life.com/ Jordann

      Thanks!

  • http://twitter.com/DanielPacker Daniel Packer

    Cable is definitely a want, but I can’t imagine living without it. For most shows, I would simply be watching them late, but there’s really no good way to get around live sports. So…I just suck up the $50 and pretend like it’s a “need”

    • http://my-alternate-life.com/ Jordann

      You can stream live sports games online, but the quality is not comparable. I guess cable is something you indulge in, there’s nothing wrong with that!

  • Jose

    Understanding the difference between a want and a need is one of the most critical things anyone can be aware of if they truly want to be in control of their spending. Unfortunately it’s a concept which many don’t fully have a grasp of. I preach this to my teenage kids constantly. Every time I hear, ” I need……” I give them a short interrogation which usually ends up with them understanding that what they were desiring is really a want and not a need. This is a great post, one that I will probably touch on in future posts on my blog http://thefindependent.com

  • Pingback: VIP Club Roundup - 17th Edition - Club Thrifty

  • http://twitter.com/PlungedinDebt Catherine

    Oh I love this post Jordann! I’m struggling right now with weight watchers. I NEED to lose weight but I WANT to join WW. I have great success with it in the past, I just don’t know I have it in me to spend the money. BUT I know I’ll need it again with future pregnancies and once you reach your goal weight and maintain for 6 weeks you get a lifetime membership…I’m so much better at figuring out wants and needs….I sometimes shop online, add stuff to my cart then clear it..haha. RE the mug- check costco and winners out next time you hit the big city ;) OR check Amazon, you can sign up for their Prime acct right now, free 1-2day shipping for 1st month then can cancel!! I ordered a few things :)

  • Pingback: I don’t care about the Super Bowl | Making Sense of Cents

  • Pingback: Goal Progress Check In & Link Love | My Alternate Life